Cargo Theft · Nov 15, 2026
How Cargo Thieves Use Stolen Insurance Certificates, and How to Protect Yours
Your certificate of insurance proves you're a real carrier. That's exactly why thieves want it.
Cargo theft has gone digital
Cargo theft is at record levels. CargoNet counted 1,120 incidents and more than $121 million in estimated losses in just the first five months of 2026, according to Insurance Journal. More and more of it is "strategic theft": instead of breaking into a trailer, thieves pose as a legitimate carrier or broker and get the load handed to them.
Once freight is gone, it rarely comes back. In an American Transportation Research Institute survey reported by Overdrive, carriers said about 73% of cargo stolen from them was never recovered. Prevention is the only defense that reliably works.
Why your COI is a target
A certificate of insurance carries your company name, MC and DOT numbers, insurer, policy numbers and contact details. That's nearly everything a thief needs to pretend to be you. With a copy, they can swap in their own phone number and email, present themselves to a broker as your company, and haul off a load under your name. You may not find out until a broker or the police call you.
That's why trucking security experts now tell owner-operators to treat their COI like sensitive information, not a flyer to hand out to anyone who asks.
Six ways carriers can protect their COI
- Check the broker before you send anything. Fake brokers and fake dispatchers ask for your COI because it looks like a routine request. Before you send it, look the company up on Check FMCSA Registration and make sure the name, MC number and phone match.
- Call back on the number FMCSA has, not the one in the email. Scammers copy real brokers' names and logos. If a request feels off, call the broker using the phone number on their FMCSA record and confirm the request is real.
- Have your agent send the certificate. Ask your insurance agent to send the COI straight to the broker, with that broker named as certificate holder. A certificate that comes from your agent is much harder to fake or misuse.
- Never post your COI publicly. Don't share it in Facebook groups, on load boards or in screenshots. Anything public can be copied and edited.
- Send a private link instead of an attachment. My Documents keeps your paperwork in one private place, and you can send a broker a link instead of emailing copies that get forwarded around.
- Watch your authority and insurance every day. If someone is using your identity, changes to your FMCSA record can be an early sign. Authority Watch checks your status every morning for free and alerts you if anything changes.
For brokers: don't trust a COI the carrier sends you
A certificate emailed by a "carrier" can be doctored. Get it from the insurance agent or a trusted third party, check that the contact details match the carrier's FMCSA record, and confirm FMCSA shows insurance on file with a free carrier check. Every check on Nightlane is also saved on the Cardano blockchain with the date, so you have permanent proof of what FMCSA showed when you booked.
Where this is heading
Today, carriers are stuck: brokers need proof of insurance, but every copy of a COI you send is a copy that can be stolen. Nightlane is working on a way for carriers to prove their coverage meets a broker's minimum without handing over the certificate at all.
Want someone guarding your paperwork while you drive?
Steady Wake Dispatch checks every broker before booking and only shares your insurance certificate with brokers it has verified. Your first load is free, then 7%, only after the broker pays you. Every load is booked under your MC with your OK.
Get my first load free →Steady Wake Dispatch · same team as NightlaneSources: Insurance Journal on record cargo theft; Overdrive on ATRI's cargo theft findings; Overdrive on safeguarding your certificate of insurance; Overdrive on guarding business identity; DAT on verifying carrier insurance. This article is general information, not legal or insurance advice.